SiliconEdge
  • Overview
    • Get Started Now
  • Psyche OS
  • Psyche Suite
  • Coaching
  • HR Solutions
    • Workforce Transitions & Outplacement
    • Japan RPO Consulting [For RPO Vendors]
    • Japan Candidate Conversions & Monetization [For Recruiting Agencies]
    • Supercharged Candidate Interviewing
    • Supercharged Candidate Recruiting
    • Supercharged Candidate Hiring
  • Media
    • Content Archives
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Interviews (audio & videos) >
      • Interviews Page 1
    • Podcasts (audio & videos) >
      • Podcasts Page 3
      • Podcasts Page 2
      • Podcasts Page 1
      • How To Easily Attract, Acquire And Stop Overpaying For Truly Top Talent
    • Library & Whitepapers >
      • Secret Silicon Valley: The Vaunted Myth and Meme of First Mover Advantage
      • Why Companies Overpay for Terrible Talent While Blocking and Rejecting Top Talent
      • Combat Stress
    • Glossary & Terms >
      • Glossary 0 - 9
      • Glossary A - F
      • Glossary G - K
      • Glossary L - P
      • Glossary Q - U
      • Glossary V - Z
  • Events
    • Career Coaching @ AfterJET 2015
    • I am 40 Now! Is It Really Game Over For Me In Japan's Job Market? (FCCJ)
    • How To Jump-Start Your Career In Japan Or Anywhere Else
    • Fire Your Recruiter & Take Control of Your Career & Your Life! (FCCJ)
    • After JET Conference 2014
    • Japan HR Society (JHRS) Annual Symposium
    • Pinterest, Box, Splunk, Millennial Media (Mitsubishi Estate's EGG/Tokyo 21C)
    • Tokyo 2.0 - Cloud Computing
    • 2nd Annual Internet Marketing Association Conference (IMA)
    • Internet Marketing Association's Summit (IMA)
    • Successful E-Marketing Initiatives (Southern California BMA)
  • About
    • Get Started
    • Site Search
    • Blog
    • Values
    • Research & Development
    • Leadership
  • 日本語

Why Recruiting Mistakes Really Happen & How To Prevent Them

11/30/2013

0 Comments

 
By James Santagata
Principal Consultant, Silicon Edge


In a recent blog post entitled "How to Deal with Pure Recruiting Mistakes", Mark Suster, a partner at Upfront Ventures gives his take on fixing recruiting or hiring mistakes. He has written some other posts on the subject as well in terms of hiring and firing fast.

In regards to hiring and firing fast, I want to be clear and fair that his post is primarily referring to startups (whose needs may be well different than a large, more established company) and is not a "just pull anyone in and see who makes it" mentality.

There is a lot of merit in moving quickly in the hiring process, in fact, many companies lose key talent because they move to slow. This slowness in hiring often comes from several factors which may include an overly subjective interview process, the inability to get all people to agree to a hire (e.g,. a group decision) or "cock-blocking" office politics.

What I want to do today, is to delve a little deeper into why recruiting mistakes happen. Why are people hired who don't work out? Is it skills, attitude, cultural fit or some other factor or combination?

There are many factors and they come from both sides of the table -- the candidate's side and the hiring firm's side. Each situation is different (ESID), but we can usually boil it down to several factors:

1. The candidate doesn't have the aptitude (skills).
2. The candidate doesn't  have the attitude (mind set and motivation).
3. The candidate doesn't mesh / can't find his or her way in the corporate culture. That is, it moves too fast or too slow for the candidate.
4, The company improperly assessed the candidates skills sets and fit.
5. The company selected the candidate to fail (e.g,. "Rank & Yank" and this candidate is the group's Sacrificial Lamb).
6. The company applied a selection shortcut -- "Oh he worked at XYZ company, must be good..."
7. The candidate's new peers or one peer sees the new hire as threat and works to remove (have fired) him or her.

Of these factors, #6 is perhaps the most critical error (along with #4) when we make hiring decisions quickly. What happens is that unless we know exactly how to interview AND are interested in a very objective, brass-tacks assessment of how the candidate really is rather than how we'd wish would be or hope the candidate is, we will get fooled and made bad decisions.

Most often this happens when we rely on Social Proof, assume the Portability of Talent (namely, the inability to identify and separate the success of the candidate from the success or support provided by the system, company or brand) and engage in Trait Ascription Bias while applying the Just World Hypothesis (sometimes known as Just World Theory, Fallacy or Phenomenon. It's a cognitive bias).

Two of the more insidious reasons the wrong hires occur is when the hiring authority's (or future peer group's) ego as well as internal politics are injected into the hiring and assessment process. This is a killer. Often resulting in hiring the wrong  talent, while driving away and 86'ing the key talent.

Here's a quickly illustration of several of these factors at play simultaneously. And just for the record, please don't read anything into the universities or companies that I have chosen to illustrate this with. They were simply chosen because of their impact in terms of having or lacking social proof and so on.

Mishire Example:
Hiring Manager / Hiring Authority:
"Hey, this candidate is a stud/studette. He/she was the Sales Director at Google so he'd/she'd make the perfect first hire for our startup sales team."

Mishire Analysis:
When you're selling for Google or IBM among other well-known firms, you'll find that about 90% of the sales mojo comes from your brand, team and resources. Conversely, when you're selling from Puntster Analytics from Podunk. Iowa, it's all about your game and skills -- pure talent.

Similar mishires are also clearly seen when hiring shortcuts are taken by hiring from direct competitors (or hiring industry insiders) and misattributing their past successes to the candidate rather than seeing what the system provided. Conversely, an excellent person may be turned away and they often are, because their stats aren't as good BUT their stats are the result of Jedi-level talent in the face of a poor brand or system. Yet they are rejected.

There are countless other examples, but another common one is the filtering out  or rejecting of highly-qualified talent because the current interviewers or team see the candidate as a clear and present danger and threat to someone's salary, position, title and/or ego on the team.

How to Deal with Pure Recruiting Mistakes

Posted on November 27, 2013
by Mark Suster 

One of the unavoidable realities of building a startup is having to fire people.

In a normal business you can often sweep bad performers under the rug and not deal with them. When you have millions or billions of dollars of revenue you can suffer a few bad performers or bad apples. You can miss a quarter’s target and not cull the inefficiencies. I’m not saying you should, but you could.

But in startups this equals death.

Death because just 3 extra non-performing employees in a company of 15 can either accelerate cash out date or can dramatically lower your productivity.

I’ve spoken about this before and my mantra, “Hire Fast, Fire Fast.”

When I first started my career I came across a term for this that has always stuck in my head and serves as a useful reminder of this mantra.

We called it “PURE.”

Previously. Undetected. Recruiting. Error.
[more] How To Deal With Pure Recruiting Mistakes >>
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    About

     SiliconEdge™ helps catalyze and drive the Productivity, Performance, Profitability, and Peace of Mind (4P's) of organizations, talent, and teams through our innovative, results-driven Talent Acceleration, Optimization, and Transformation programs.

    Picture

    Archives (by date)

    May 2022
    September 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    June 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    June 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    January 2013

    Categories

    All
    Akio Morita
    Apple
    Asia Business
    Asia-pacific Coaching Alliance
    Bootstrap
    Bootstrapped Startups
    Bootstrapped Startups
    Business Acumen
    Business Acumen
    Business Myths
    Business Myths
    China Business
    Cloud Computing
    Coaching 2.0
    Coaching 2.0
    Company Culture
    Competition
    Compliance
    Conferences
    Consultants
    Creativity
    Diversity
    Divine Right
    Economics
    Elon Musk
    Employee Engagement
    Events
    Executive Coaching
    Executive Coaching
    Failures
    Genius
    Growth Hacking
    Hica
    High Impact Coaching
    High-impact Coaching
    High-impact Coaching Alliance
    High-impact Training
    High-impact-training
    High-impact-training
    Hiring
    Humor
    Incumbents
    Influence
    Innovation
    Instructors
    Interviews
    Iptv
    Japan Business
    Japanese Creativity
    Japanese Innovation
    Japanese Leadership
    Korean Creativity
    Korean Innovation
    Korean Startups
    Leadership
    Lean-in
    Marketing
    Marketing Myopia
    Marketing Myopia
    Mpeg-21
    Mpeg 4
    Mpeg-4
    Mpeg-7
    Myths & Memes
    Myths Memes
    Netflix
    No Box Thinking
    No Box Thinking
    Office Politics
    Ondemand Media
    Organizational Power
    Persuasion
    Ping And Paint
    Political Correctness
    Psychological Jujutsu
    Public Speaking
    Recruiting
    Regulatory Capture
    Regulatory Capture
    Rent Seeking
    Rent-seeking
    Roukan
    Siliconedge
    Siliconedge Announcements
    Siliconedge Hiring
    Siliconedge In The News
    Siliconedge Press Interviews
    Siliconedge Press Mentions
    Siliconedge Website
    Silicon Valley
    Silicon Valley
    Situational Awareness
    Social Engineering
    Sonar And Radar
    Startups
    Stealth
    Stealth Startups
    Steve Jobs
    Steve Jobs
    Strategy
    Streaming Media
    Supercharged Hiring
    Talent Management
    Talent Management
    Technology
    Technology Adoption Lifecycle
    Tech Startups
    Tokyo
    Validation
    Venture-capital
    Venturecapital
    War For Talent
    War On Talent
    Women Leaders
    Women Leadership
    Work Culture
    Work Environment

    RSS Feed

ActiveEQ (tm)

​© Copyright 2007-2025 SiliconEdge™ Co. Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
PSI Script (tm)
  • Overview
    • Get Started Now
  • Psyche OS
  • Psyche Suite
  • Coaching
  • HR Solutions
    • Workforce Transitions & Outplacement
    • Japan RPO Consulting [For RPO Vendors]
    • Japan Candidate Conversions & Monetization [For Recruiting Agencies]
    • Supercharged Candidate Interviewing
    • Supercharged Candidate Recruiting
    • Supercharged Candidate Hiring
  • Media
    • Content Archives
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Interviews (audio & videos) >
      • Interviews Page 1
    • Podcasts (audio & videos) >
      • Podcasts Page 3
      • Podcasts Page 2
      • Podcasts Page 1
      • How To Easily Attract, Acquire And Stop Overpaying For Truly Top Talent
    • Library & Whitepapers >
      • Secret Silicon Valley: The Vaunted Myth and Meme of First Mover Advantage
      • Why Companies Overpay for Terrible Talent While Blocking and Rejecting Top Talent
      • Combat Stress
    • Glossary & Terms >
      • Glossary 0 - 9
      • Glossary A - F
      • Glossary G - K
      • Glossary L - P
      • Glossary Q - U
      • Glossary V - Z
  • Events
    • Career Coaching @ AfterJET 2015
    • I am 40 Now! Is It Really Game Over For Me In Japan's Job Market? (FCCJ)
    • How To Jump-Start Your Career In Japan Or Anywhere Else
    • Fire Your Recruiter & Take Control of Your Career & Your Life! (FCCJ)
    • After JET Conference 2014
    • Japan HR Society (JHRS) Annual Symposium
    • Pinterest, Box, Splunk, Millennial Media (Mitsubishi Estate's EGG/Tokyo 21C)
    • Tokyo 2.0 - Cloud Computing
    • 2nd Annual Internet Marketing Association Conference (IMA)
    • Internet Marketing Association's Summit (IMA)
    • Successful E-Marketing Initiatives (Southern California BMA)
  • About
    • Get Started
    • Site Search
    • Blog
    • Values
    • Research & Development
    • Leadership
  • 日本語